Don't know about which is better but I like the 450 a lot.Accurate,hornady stuff easy to get for it,and recoil not bad at all to me.I was impressed the most by how accurate the 450 can be.The 458 seemed to cost a lot more and hard to get pistol brass in a AR would make cost higher.
I don't think the 458 will do anything the 450 can't do a lot cheaper.