Page 4 of 4

Re: Lee FCD Mod Step-By-Step w/images

PostPosted: Sat Nov 05, 2016 9:33 pm
by Hoot
dantheman wrote:Someone should market these on Ebay
Dan


Dan, I worked for many years in Manufacturing and Product Test Engineering. Even with all my best effort to control the consistency of the dozen or so that I've made, no two turned out exactly the same. The up front cost to make tooling that manufactures them consistently, would take a lifetime recovering the cost from onesy twosy sales on Ebay, at a price that would move product. That's just one challenge. My experience has also been that no two people who reload are the same. While a more experienced person might get excellent results, the less experienced person might struggle and that can lead to costs due to returns from unsatisfied customers. People are not bashful about voicing their displeasure on Ebay, even when a refund comes to them. Bad feedback from even a few customers, can overshadow sales to many satisfied ones. Then there's the liability from some cowboy blowing up his overloaded rounds. The list of drawbacks goes on.
Reloading walks a fine line between art and science. My experience has been that science is the greater variable than the art part of it. Reliance upon powder and primer performance as if its gospel, while reloading at or near the top of the safety window, is going to catch up with even the most fastidious person and not every reloader bothers to spend more time turning pages and reading as they do pulling on that press handle. :roll:

Hoot

Re: Lee FCD Mod Step-By-Step w/images

PostPosted: Sun Nov 06, 2016 10:27 am
by lungingturtle2
Amen Hoot, as usual you are right on target. When you make something foolproof there are many that look on it as a challenge.

Re: Lee FCD Mod Step-By-Step w/images

PostPosted: Sun Nov 06, 2016 10:57 pm
by Texas Sheepdawg
Hoot wrote:
dantheman wrote:Someone should market these on Ebay
Dan


Dan, I worked for many years in Manufacturing and Product Test Engineering. Even with all my best effort to control the consistency of the dozen or so that I've made, no two turned out exactly the same. The up front cost to make tooling that manufactures them consistently, would take a lifetime recovering the cost from onesy twosy sales on Ebay, at a price that would move product. That's just one challenge. My experience has also been that no two people who reload are the same. While a more experienced person might get excellent results, the less experienced person might struggle and that can lead to costs due to returns from unsatisfied customers. People are not bashful about voicing their displeasure on Ebay, even when a refund comes to them. Bad feedback from even a few customers, can overshadow sales to many satisfied ones. Then there's the liability from some cowboy blowing up his overloaded rounds. The list of drawbacks goes on.
Reloading walks a fine line between art and science. My experience has been that science is the greater variable than the art part of it. Reliance upon powder and primer performance as if its gospel, while reloading at or near the top of the safety window, is going to catch up with even the most fastidious person and not every reloader bothers to spend more time turning pages and reading as they do pulling on that press handle. :roll:

Hoot

Dittos Hoot. And I have now found that my screaming 230 Grain FMJs don't need all that powder in the single shot and bolt actions. So. Any of you guys thinking about using AR type hand loads in a bolt action, back it back down to 38 grains of LG, use your LSC and work up but IMHO, anything above 40-41 grains is insane in a 1:16 twist bolt actions and single shots.

Re: Lee FCD Mod Step-By-Step w/images

PostPosted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 6:01 am
by Hoot
Texas Sheepdawg wrote:Dittos Hoot. And I have now found that my screaming 230 Grain FMJs don't need all that powder in the single shot and bolt actions. So. Any of you guys thinking about using AR type hand loads in a bolt action, back it back down to 38 grains of LG, use your LSC and work up but IMHO, anything above 40-41 grains is insane in a 1:16 twist bolt actions and single shots.


Not to diverge from the topic, but I had a 1:16 AR barrel to play with once upon a time. The amount of gas lost in the DI action of a AR does not square 1:1 with the increase in pressure and velocity in a bolt action or single shot. The faster 1:16 twist adds more resistance to the bullet's travel down the bore and results in greater pressure. It milks more energy from the power charge in this caliber, so Dawg's advice to start lower is good advice. In the case of 1:24 single shots and bolt actions, that difference in resultant velocity can be attributed to the lack of gas lost. If you want to see how it adds up in an AR platform, just shoot a few rounds and then rotate the gas block to seal off the port and see how the velocity changes.

Hoot